Fog of War
“Many intelligence reports in war are contradictory;
even more are false, and most are
uncertain.”
—Karl von Clausewitz
The term "Fog of War" was coined by Clausewitz. I found the above quote the in manual for CC:E which is full of amusing and thought-provoking quotes.
I played CC:E one time w/ Brian and I really enjoyed it. I had a strong feeling of narrative, barely controlled chaos, and tension. I won that game partially because neither of us completely understood the rules, and partially because of a single tempo.
“It is even better to act quickly and err than to
hesitate until the time of action is past.”
—Karl von Clausewitz
I have never been in battle, and I hope to maintain a perfect record in this regard. Nevertheless, CC:E seems to capture the "intellectual essence" of the thing w/o the need to change my underwear. The chaos, the narrative, the tension are all really appealling to me.
So what I'm saying is that I was all set to buy one in the next few months now that I've gotten some use out of BL.
But...then I read about Tide of Iron. At first the minis made me think it was a lot like M44, and I figured I wasn't interested. Then I read Tom Vassel's review, and it seems the game is a lot more hard-core than I thought. My guess is that it won't be nearly as chaotic and out-of-control as CC:E which is both good and bad.
The other big difference between the two is that ToI could theoretically be played solo, whereas CC:E, being a card driven game, would be awful solo. In the next few months (years?) it'll be hard for me to schedule lots of time, and a game w/ solo ability has some appeal.
Decisions, decisions...
Labels: ramblings
6 Comments:
A wise man once said, "Don't ask why, just buy."
Ted, I'll own both, so you'll have a good opportunity to demo.
I still catch myself softly mumbling, "My Precious...." whenever I seen an ad for ToI.
I enjoy CC:E because of its simplicity.... its 'stremlinededness'. I'll never have the time and energy to dedicate to ASL. I like the idea of squad-level WWII wargaming, but ASL and maybe SK too may be a bit too much. CC:E just provides enough for me to enjoy the genre. Of course, I also love the chaos and random events that can happen in combat (even when they are frustratingly impossible). A true gem.
Loving tanks, I've always wanted to play Lock N' Load more.
ToI seems to me more like Memoir 44 on steroids...which is not necessarily a bad thing. I'm on a wait-and-see stance with this one. I think I'm turning into a chit-and-block-pushing grognard.
Lets put it this way... if and when I sell Memoir, I'll get ToI.
> A wise man once said
Steve, was that Clausewitz too?
I think it was Sun Tzu...
Post a Comment
<< Home